18 Popular Indianapolis Neighborhoods: Where to Live in Indianapolis in 2023

Located in the heart of Indiana, Indianapolis is a vibrant city known for its rich history, bustling downtown, and diverse neighborhoods. Residents flock to Indianapolis for its community feel, arts and culture scene, sports teams, and more. Whether you’re looking for the trendy vibe of Broad Ripple, the charming historic homes of Fletcher Place, or the arts district of Fountain Square, there is a neighborhood in Indianapolis for every lifestyle.

To help you find the right area to live in, Redfin is here to help you explore 18 popular Indianapolis neighborhoods. Whether you’re looking for an apartment in the heart of downtown or to buy a home in Indianapolis, let’s dive into these popular neighborhoods.

1. Broad Ripple

Broad Ripple is a vibrant neighborhood with an eclectic mix of shops, restaurants, and entertainment venues. The area is also home to the Monon Trail, a popular recreational path that attracts runners, walkers, and cyclists. Additionally, Broad Ripple features Broad Ripple Park, which offers green space, playgrounds, and sports fields. One of the historic places in the area is the Vogue Theater, a beloved music venue that has been a staple in the neighborhood for decades.

Broad Ripple offers a variety of housing types, including bungalows, cottages, and apartments in architectural styles like Tudor Revival and Craftsman.

Median Sale Price: $344,000

Homes for Sale in Broad Ripple | Apartments for Rent in Broad Ripple

2. Butler-Tarkington

The Butler-Tarkington neighborhood is on the north side of Indianapolis and is home to Butler University. This area offers a suburban feel with beautiful tree-lined streets and historic homes. Things to do in Butler-Tarkington include seeing a show at Clowes Memorial Hall and spending time outdoors in nearby Tarkington Park. Butler-Tarkington features a mix of housing types, including single-family homes and some apartments. The architectural styles range from charming Tudor Revival to Colonial Revival homes.

Median Sale Price: $290,000

Homes for Sale in Butler-Tarkington | Apartments for Rent in Butler-Tarkington

3. Castleton

The Castleton neighborhood in northeast Indianapolis offers a blend of residential living and commercial spaces. It’s home to the popular Castleton Square Mall, which provides a wide range of shopping and dining options. Castleton is also known for its numerous parks, including Sahm Park and the White River, which offer opportunities for outdoor activities. In Castleton, you’ll find various housing options, including single-family homes, townhomes, and some apartments.

Median Sale Price: $226,000

Homes for Sale in Castleton | Apartments for Rent in Castleton

4. Chatham Arch

Chatham Arch is in the heart of Indianapolis, just outside of downtown. This historic neighborhood has charming Victorian homes and proximity to downtown attractions such as the Indiana State Capitol and Lucas Oil Stadium. Residents can enjoy the nearby Mass Ave district with its eclectic mix of restaurants, shops, and theaters.

Chatham Arch features a variety of housing types and architectural styles, including beautifully restored Victorian mansions, townhouses, and modern condos. The neighborhood’s historic charm blends seamlessly with contemporary urban living.

Median Sale Price: $408,000

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,175 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $1,140

Homes for Sale in Chatham Arch | Apartments for Rent in Chatham Arch

5. Downtown Indianapolis

Downtown Indianapolis, also called Mile Square, has a vibrant atmosphere and bustling city life. Major attractions in this neighborhood include the famous Monument Circle, which features the Soldiers & Sailors Monument, the Indiana Historical Society, the Indiana State Capitol, and Old National Centre. The area also has several beautiful parks, including University Park and the Indianapolis Canal Walk.

Downtown Indianapolis is characterized by a mix of housing types and architectural styles. You can find everything from historic apartment buildings to modern loft-style condos.

Median Sale Price: $384,000

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,524 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $1,913

Homes for Sale in Downtown Indianapolis | Apartments for Rent in Downtown Indianapolis

6. Eagle Creek

Eagle Creek has beautiful natural surroundings, making it a excellent area for those looking to be close to nature while living in a city. It’s home to Eagle Creek Park, one of the largest city parks in the country, offering activities such as boating, fishing, hiking, and bird watching. The neighborhood is also close to the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, where the famous Indy 500 race takes place. Eagle Creek offers a variety of housing types, including single-family homes, townhouses, and apartments.

Median Sale Price: $250,000

Homes for Sale in Eagle Creek | Apartments for Rent in Eagle Creek

7. Fall Creek Place

Fall Creek Place has charming historic homes, tree-lined streets, and proximity to downtown. Major attractions include the Fall Creek Trail, a well-known pedestrian and biking trail. Several parks are nearby, such as Fall Creek Gardens and George E. Kessler Park.

Fall Creek Place is home to various housing types, including beautifully restored Victorian homes and modern townhouses – the architectural styles in the neighborhood range from Queen Anne and Craftsman to Colonial and Italianate.

Median Sale Price: $445,000

Homes for Sale in Fall Creek Place | Apartments for Rent in Fall Creek Place

8. Fletcher Place

Just south of downtown is Fletcher Place, highlighted by its vibrant arts and culinary scene. The neighborhood is home to a few green spaces, like Edna Balz Lacy Family Park. The housing types in Fletcher Place include a mix of historic homes, modern townhouses, and newly constructed apartments. The architectural styles range from beautifully restored Victorian houses to sleek contemporary designs.

Median Sale Price: $355,000

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,590 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $2,420

Homes for Sale in Fletcher Place | Apartments for Rent in Fletcher Place

9. Fountain Square

Fountain Square has a historic architectural charm and quirky vibe. The neighborhood is home to a variety of restaurants, bars, art galleries, and live music venues like HI-FI Indy & HI-FI Annex. One of its major attractions is the Fountain Square Theatre Building, which houses a theater, ballroom, and duckpin bowling alley. The neighborhood is also home to the Pleasant Run Trail. Fountain Square offers a blend of housing types and architectural styles, including historic Victorian homes and modern new builds.

Median Sale Price: $285,000

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,548 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $2,393

Homes for Sale in Fountain Square | Apartments for Rent in Fountain Square

10. Garfield Park

Garfield Park is located south of downtown Indianapolis and is home to a beautiful park of the same name. The park features a conservatory, sunken gardens, a fountain, and a playground. In addition to the park, Garfield Park also offers historic places such as the Garfield Park Arts Center (GPAC), which features art exhibitions and classes. Garfield Park offers a variety of housing types, including single-family homes and apartments, ranging in styles from Craftsman to Colonial Revival.

Median Sale Price: $196,950

Homes for Sale in Garfield Park | Apartments for Rent in Garfield Park

11. Herron-Morton Place

The Herron-Morton Place area is filled with historic architecture and tree-lined streets. The neighborhood is home to several major attractions, including the Herron-Morton Place Park and the Footlite Musicals. There are also many historic places within walking distance such as the Old Northside Historic District.

The housing types in Herron-Morton Place include beautifully restored Victorian and Queen Anne-style homes, along with some newer construction. The neighborhood offers a mix of single-family homes and townhouses, making it a great place to live for those who appreciate historic charm and modern amenities.

Median Sale Price: $495,000

Homes for Sale in Herron-Morton Place | Apartments for Rent in Herron-Morton Place

12. Holy Cross

Holy Cross is east of downtown and full of charm. The area also has several parks, including Highland Park and the Monon Trail. Holy Cross is filled with beautifully restored homes and showcases a mix of architectural styles, including Victorian, Queen Anne, and Italianate.

Median Sale Price: $420,000

Homes for Sale in Holy Cross | Apartments for Rent in Holy Cross

13. Irvington

Irvington is located on the east side of Indianapolis. It is known for the Irving Theatre, which hosts live performances and film screenings, and the Irvington Halloween Festival, a popular annual event. The neighborhood has several parks, including Ellenberger Park, which features a swimming pool, tennis courts, and a playground. Historic places in Irvington include the Benton House, a Victorian-era home that is now a museum.

Irvington offers a variety of housing types, including historic bungalows, Tudor-style homes, and Victorian houses. The architectural styles in the neighborhood range from Craftsman and Colonial Revival to Queen Anne and Gothic Revival.

Median Sale Price: $214,900

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $750 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $799

Homes for Sale in Irvington | Apartments for Rent in Irvington

14. Mapleton-Fall Creek

Mapleton-Fall Creek is located in the northeast part of Indianapolis. The area is near the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis and the Indiana State Fairgrounds. Mapleton-Fall Creek features a mix of housing types, including single-family homes, apartments, and townhouses. For example, the architectural styles in the neighborhood range from Victorian and Craftsman, to Colonial and bungalow-style homes.

Median Sale Price: $330,000

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,295 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $1,645

Homes for Sale in Mapleton-Fall Creek | Apartments for Rent in Mapleton-Fall Creek

15. Mass Ave

Mass Ave is located in downtown Indianapolis and is known for its lively arts and culture scene. It’s home to numerous art galleries, theaters, and trendy boutiques. The neighborhood is also famous for its historic landmarks, such as the Athenaeum, a German-American building that hosts events and houses a theater. The housing types in Mass Ave consist of mainly apartments and lofts, many of which feature unique architectural styles, such as Victorian and Art Deco influences.

Median Sale Price: $420,235

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,454 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $2,045

Homes for Sale in Mass Ave | Apartments for Rent in Mass Ave

16. Meridian-Kessler

Meridian-Kessler is home to several major attractions, such as the Indianapolis Opera, and plenty of excellent local restaurants. You’ll find charming bungalows, Tudor-style homes, and Colonial Revival houses throughout the Meridian-Kessler neighborhood.

Median Sale Price: $463,500

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,375 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $1,791

Homes for Sale in Meridian-Kessler | Apartments for Rent in Meridian-Kessler

17. Near Northside

The Near Northside is a large neighborhood just north of downtown Indianapolis. Some major attractions in the area include the Benjamin Harrison Presidential Site, the 23rd President’s home, which features exhibits and tours. The neighborhood also offers several parks for outdoor activities, such as Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Park.  Near Northside also has many historic places, including the Old Northside Historic District. The housing types in Near Northside vary, with a mix of single-family homes, townhouses, and apartments in styles ranging from Victorian to Craftsman.

Median Sale Price: $400,000

Average Rent 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,319 | Average Rent 2-Bedroom Apartment: $1,717

Homes for Sale in Near Northside | Apartments for Rent in Near Northside

18. St. Joseph

St. Joseph is known for its close proximity to downtown. There are many historic sites in the area, like Calvin I. Fletcher House and the nearby American Legion Mall. St. Joseph offers plenty of  housing options, including single-family homes, townhouses, and apartments. The architectural styles in the neighborhood vary, with a combination of historic houses and modern developments.

Median Sale Price: $299,000

Homes for Sale in St. Joseph | Apartments for Rent in St. Joseph

Methodology: All neighborhoods must be listed as a “neighborhood” on Redfin.com. Median home sale price data from the Redfin Data Center during September 2023. Average rental data from Rent.com during September 2023.

The post 18 Popular Indianapolis Neighborhoods: Where to Live in Indianapolis in 2023 appeared first on Redfin | Real Estate Tips for Home Buying, Selling & More.