How High-Priced Homes Changed the Mortgage Game in 2021

The housing market in 2021 was one for the record books. With prices at historic highs and the number of listings in a deep hole, open houses looked like Black Friday sales and many would-be buyers were elbowed out of the melee.

In 2021, the share of buyers paying all cash for home purchases trended higher in the United States, but the overwhelming majority of home sales still involved mortgages. Unfortunately, as with every year, many 2021 mortgage applications were met with denials.

The following analysis of the 7.1 million mortgage applications filed that year uncovers several markers of the unusual homebuying market: a steep rise in loan amounts, an increase in the number of mortgage denials directly tied to high-priced homes, and some changes in loan types that reflect stiff competition.

Higher home prices = bigger loans

Mortgages for single-family homes averaged $343,000 in 2021. That’s a 15% increase from the 2020 average. The jump is particularly notable when you consider these mortgages rose just 8% from 2019 to 2020, a one-year increase that includes the beginning of home prices’ precipitous climb.

Demand for homes has been high for the past few years, and this competition and high prices mean that some potential buyers can’t be successful. As the size of the average mortgage balloons by 15%, for instance, people already stretching their homebuying budget can’t keep up.

Thankfully, in 2022, the number of listed homes has begun to increase in many markets. Price growth has slowed and fewer home sales are ending with a bidding war. But now buyers must contend with higher mortgage rates — a single percentage point change from 5% to 6% on a $343,000 mortgage, for instance, means $215 more each month on a house payment and a difference of roughly $77,500 in interest over the life of the loan.

Approved, denied: Have outcomes changed?

In 2021, lenders processed some 7.1 million mortgage applications, up 8% or about a half million from the year before. Among those, 73% resulted in loan originations and 7% resulted in denials. The remainder were closed for incompleteness or approved but not originated.

Over the past few years, the rates of denials and originations haven’t changed much. In 2020, for example, 8% of applications were denied and 73% resulted in loan originations. In 2019, those shares were virtually identical.

But, the reasons for these denials have changed slightly.

Change in 2021 denial reasons reflects high-priced market

How much debt a person carries relative to how much money they bring home, or their debt-to-income ratio, plays a significant role in their chances of mortgage approval. And DTI ratio was (once again) the most commonly cited reason for denials in 2021, accounting for 31% of refused loans.

However, lenders were denying more loans because of overpriced homes.

Collateral refers to the actual value of the home being purchased relative to the amount being borrowed. When an appraisal comes in low, the bank would be taking a much bigger risk by issuing the loan — in a worst-case scenario, the collateral it held (the house) wouldn’t be enough to cover what’s owed.

Insufficient collateral accounted for 16% of mortgage denials in 2021, after just 13% in 2020. It tied with credit history for the second-most common primary reason for denials. Three percentage points may not seem significant, but that change accounts for 14,300 more denials, while the number denied for credit history fell by nearly 22,000.

Advice for buyers: Buyers faced with denials for debt-to-income ratio or credit history have their marching orders: When lending standards are high, entering the market with less debt and a robust credit history increases your chances for approval. A denial based on collateral isn’t quite as straightforward, but there are options.

If possible, paying the difference between the appraisal and the amount you offered is the simplest. By increasing your down payment, you decrease how much you have to borrow, closing the gap between the appraisal and loan amount. You can also ask for a review of the appraisal if you think it’s wrong, or renegotiate the price with the seller. Finally, if you’ve written an appraisal contingency in your offer to purchase, you can walk away — a tough thing to do when you’ve actually gone under contract in this competitive market.

Loan types signal steep competition

While the number of new mortgages rose by 9% overall in 2021, that bump conceals some interesting changes across loan types.

Conventional mortgages typically have the strictest standards for approval, while government-backed loans like FHA and USDA loans are generally available to people with lower credit scores and down payments. These programs make homeownership attainable for borrowers who may otherwise be wedged out.

Unfortunately, these loans can look less competitive to home sellers — they may take longer to fund, have a reputation for tougher appraisal standards, and may be seen as more at risk of falling apart before the closing date.

With multiple offers on their kitchen tables, sellers are likely to opt for the biggest offers and easiest transactions. Cash is king, of course, but if the offer involves a mortgage, conventional loans typically move to the top of the stack.

This is just one additional way the 2021 housing market pushed out would-be buyers on the edge of qualifying for a home purchase.

Advice for buyers: In the current market, buying a home with a USDA or FHA loan isn’t impossible, just more difficult. It will take finding the right seller and the right home, but you can make your offer more competitive by easing the transaction: Come with a preapproval, ask for repairs after the inspection only if they reach a certain dollar amount threshold and work with a real estate agent who’s familiar with the local market and different loan types.

This article was from James Madison University / The Breeze and was legally licensed through the Industry Dive Content Marketplace. Please direct all licensing questions to [email protected].